Quote of the month:
Chess is a game of bad moves. - Andrew Soltis         

Issue 14 (17 Oct. 2007)

 

Home    |     Links     |     Archives     |       Leave a Message      |     Chess Clippings


proud to be a  
chess player 

Home
Links
Archives
Leave a message
Chess Clippings
  


By Larry Parr 
Chess Life Editor 1984 - 1988
Author

WORSE THAN A CRIME?   
(FINAL)  

WHEN CHESS GODS BLUNDER (X)

       If Keres provides a case text on how to appraise carefully a blunder or apparent blunder, then Savielly Tartakower quickly grabbed some pseudo-blunder bait like a starved tuna in a game against Capablanca.  

Savielly Tartakower -  Jose Capablanca New York, 1924 (King’s Gambit Accepted )

       1. e4 e5  2. f4 exf4  3. Be2 d5  4. exd5 Nf6  5. c4 c6  6. d4 Bb4+!  7. Kf1 cxd5  8. Bxf4?! dxc4

       Has Capablanca blundered a piece?  In the tournament book, Alekhine wrote of Black’s 
8th move, “This natural move is bound up with a bit of finesse, however.”     

Capablanca 

Tartakower (to play)

       9. Bxb8??

       Tartakower later admitted that he actually believed the great Cuban had pitched a piece 
here, expecting 9. ... Rxb8  10. Qa4+, winning the Bishop on b4.   Alekhine wrote rather 
cruelly in the tournament book that Tartakower “plainly thinks that the world’s champion 
has simply left a piece to be taken.”  A much better move is 9. Bxc4.

       9. ... Nd5!!

       There was, then, no blunder.  Tartakower moved too quickly in his excitement, and 
Capa stands much better.  Perhaps his game is already won.

       10. Kf2 Rxb8  11. Bxc4 0-0  12. Nf3?

       His high hopes dashed, White falls apart.  The best chance was 12. Bxd5.

       12.   ... Nf6!  13. Nc3 b5!  14. Bd3 Ng4+  15. Kg1 Bb7  16. Bf5 Bxf3  17. gxf3 Ne3  18. Bxh7+ Kh8!  19. Qd3 Bxc3  20. bxc3 Nd5  21. Be4 Nf4  22. Qd2 Qh4  23. Kf1 f5  24. Bc6 Rf6  25. d5 Rd8  26. Rd1 Rxc6  27. dxc6 Rxd2  28. Rxd2 Ne6  29. Rd6 Qc4+  30. Kg2 Qe2, White resigns

      QUICK GLANCE

  

Last updated 17 October  2007